The frequency with which cheating occurs is probably the
most studied aspect of academic cheating.
How Do We Know What We Know About Cheating?
• direct observation (unreliable)
• self-report surveys
• surveys asking about the behavior of others rather
than oneself
• surveys utilizing the Random Response Technique
• statistical methods
• experimental methods (e.g., self-grading after tests
have been secretly photocopied)
CHEATING IN ELEMENTARY & MIDDLE SCHOOL
• 12% percentage of third graders who cheated (James,
1933)
• 30% percentage of students who cheated scoring,
their own tests (Feldman & Feldman, 1967)
• 39% say they have cheated at least once; 15% say
they have cheated a few or many times (Brandes, 1986)
• 64% say cheating is "a serious problem"
at their school (Evans & Craig, 1990)
• >50% percentage of grade 4-6 children near Los
Angeles who cheated using bogus key (Houser, 1978)
CHEATING IN HIGH SCHOOL
• 68% Percentage of 1,300 students surveyed by telephone
who, when asked to rate severity of cheating, reported the
problem as "somewhat serious" or "very serious"
(Johnson & Farkas, 1997)
• 97% Percentage of 2,265 California students surveyed
who report witnessing others cheat (Brandes, 1986)
• 75% Percentage of students who report cheating at
least once by copying answers or using crib sheets (Brandes,
1986)
• 38% Percentage of students who have used pre-arranged
signaling during a test (Brandes, 1986)
• 42% Percentage of students who have obtained unfair
access to test materials before a test (Brandes, 1986)
• 88% Percentage who agree "students in a class
usually know when cheating is going on" (Evans and
Craig, 1990)
• 77% Percentage who agree that cheating is a serious
problem in their school (Evans and Craig, 1990)
• 45% Percentage of students who cheated scoring their
own tests (Feldman & Feldman (1967)
• 10% rise-- Large surveys on perceptions of cheating
were repeated in three decades (Schab 1969, 1979, 1989);
average 10% rise in perceived cheating during that time
• 76% College students surveyed as to whether they
cheated during high school; range from 51 % to 83% (average
76%). Of these, 80% copied or used crib notes (Davis, Grover,
Becker & McGregor, 1992)
• 34% Percentage who say "Almost everybody does
it" in reference to
• cheating; another 54% say it's "fairly common"
and less than 1 % say it "never happens" (Who's
Who Among American High School Students, 1993, 1994)
CHEATING IN COLLEGE (adapted from Cizek, 1999)
• 66% Students who report cheating at least once (Sherrill,
Salisbury, Horowitz, & Friedman, 1971)
• 32% Students who say they cheat "at every opportunity"
(Sherrill, Salisbury, Horowitz, & Friedman, 1971)
• 91 % Students who report cheating at least once
(Smith, Ryan & Diggins, 1972)
• 76-43% Say that they've cheated vs. percentage who
say they cheat in one or more of their current classes (Baird,
1980)
• 82% Admit to "academic misconduct" (Stern
& Havlicek, 1986)
• 54% Students who say they've cheated in the last
year (Haines, Diekhoff, LaBeff, & Clark, 1986)
• 9-64% Women at small private liberal arts college
who admit to cheating vs. men at regional university who
admit to cheating (Davis, Grover, Becker, & McGregor,
1992—the lowest and highest prevalences of cheating
in their samples, respectively)
• 74% Say they've witnessed cheating during an examination
Jendrek (1992)
• 81-99% Say they've cheated vs. percentage who say
others have cheated (Greene and Saxe, 1992)
• 42% Admit to cheating on at least once examination
(Kerkvliet, 1994)
• 68% Admit to cheating at least once (Hollinger &
Lanza-Kaduce, 1996)
• 90% Admit to cheating at least once (Graham, Monday,
O'Brien, & Steffen, 1994)
SUMMARY: from elementary school to college, nearly all
students have seen someone cheat, about two-thirds say they've
cheated at least once, and about a third cheat regularly.
Author: Dr. Bob Bramucci